Panel rules Arsenal were denied penalty in Hull City match
Story updated
Quick read
11-second readThe Premier League’s Key Match Incidents Panel has ruled that Arsenal were denied a penalty in their 1–0 win over Hull City. The panel said Kai Havertz should have received the spot-kick and that the video assistant should have intervened.

Full story
It found that Kai Havertz should have been awarded a penalty after a holding foul by Nobel Mendy. The on-field referee and VAR both declined to award the penalty as Havertz occupied an offside position.
The panel said that because Mendy’s obvious holding occurred earlier than Havertz’s possible offside, the timing was decisive. It backed the refusal to grant an earlier penalty for a separate challenge by Mendy. The VAR intervention itself was judged correct, but not the on-field review's result. The panel’s verdict means the original call was wrong.
In an Arsenal match, a panel has found an incorrect decision that should have been overturned for the fifth time in 10 games. Four of those five went against Arsenal, including a missed penalty for Bruno Guimaraes against Aston Villa and an unpunished red-card situation for Villa. The one decision in Arsenal’s favour involved Alexander Isak’s penalty claim against Liverpool.
As of 18 November, Arsenal sit first in the Premier League with 27 points from 10 matches. Their next scheduled fixture is Newcastle versus Arsenal on 21 November, followed by Arsenal versus Borussia Dortmund in the Champions League on 24 November. Neither fixture is a confirmed lineup.
What this means
The result stands and no further disciplinary or retrospective action is mentioned. Arsenal face Newcastle away and Borussia Dortmund at home in their next scheduled games.
What’s your take?
React, join the discussion or share this story with your fans.
Sources
- ReportingDaily Cannon ↗
- Club dataAPI-Football ↗
THE NEXT STORY STARTS HERE
Keep reading
More stories connected to this one. Find your next talking point.
Kai Havertz should have been awarded penalty against Hull, KMI panel finds
An independent panel has unanimously ruled that Arsenal were incorrectly denied a penalty against Hull for a foul on Kai Havertz while the German was in an offside position.The…
The Independent‘Arsenal should have been awarded a penalty’ in Hull win as Premier League panel confirm incorrect offside
Arsenal were controversially denied a spot-kick during 1-0 win over Hull before the international breakThe Premier League’s Key Match Incidents Panel has voted unanimously that…
Evening StandardArsenal denied clear penalty vs Hull
Arsenal have received official confirmation that they were the victims of a significant officiating error during their recent Premier League clash with Hull City.
GOALBayern Munich News: Arsenal wants Michael Olise; FC Barcelona eyeing Man City’s Josko Gvardiol?; and MORE!
Gunners keeping close tabs on Olise? (Football Transfers) Bayern Munich star Michael Olise will continue to be one of the most sought-after and speculated-upon players in the…
Bavarian Football WorksArsenal and Man City face £80m transfer battle for RB Leipzig winger Antonio Nusa
Arsenal and Manchester City are reportedly interested in signing RB Leipzig winger Antonio Nusa, with the Norwegian international attracting growing attention ahead of the…
CaughtOffsideArsenal and Manchester City reportedly interested in Leipzig winger Antonio Nusa
Antonio Nusa, the RB Leipzig winger, is reportedly of interest to Manchester City and Arsenal. The 21-year-old is under contract until 2029 and could cost from £70 million to…
CaughtOffsideThe stands
0 commentsHave your say. Keep it about football. Guest comments are reviewed before appearing publicly.






Be the first to start the conversation.