FOOTBALL · THE CONVERSATION STARTS HERE

Newcastle United player review splits squad into solution and problem groups

Story updated

Quick read

9-second read

Fabian Schar, Dan Burn, Malick Thiaw, Amar Dedic, Lukas Hornicek, Lewis Miley, Lewis Hall, and Sean Steur are viewed by a Newcastle United assessment as players who are part of the solution.

Kickjolly
Newcastle United Players Clapping Away Fans at Crystal Palace Selhurst Park
The Mag · feed photo

Full story

The assessment splits the Newcastle United squad into players viewed as part of the answer and those seen as part of the problem. Lukas Hornicek, Lewis Miley, Sean Steur, Amar Dedic, Lewis Hall, Malick Thiaw, Dan Burn and Fabian Schar are named in the solution group, with Schar described as backup for the remainder of the season. The writer says this is not a scientific exercise and is based on what they have seen with their own eyes. Being part of the solution does not mean being viewed as world beaters.

Tino Livramento is listed as part of the problem but marked yes, because of fitness concerns despite his quality. Sven Botman is marked maybe after two major operations and injuries, following a brilliant 2022-23 season when Newcastle had the best Premier League defence. Joelinton is marked no, with injuries and his age cited, along with a view that he does not fit a mobile passing game. Jacob Ramsey is marked maybe, with the writer saying the end of the season should clarify his role.

Joe Willock and Jacob Murphy are both marked no, with Willock described as brilliant in 2022-23 before bad injuries and Murphy said to no longer produce enough over whole matches. Harvey Barnes and Anthony Elanga are marked maybe, while Yoane Wissa is also marked maybe. Barnes is called Newcastle’s best finisher when he reaches goalscoring positions, but his overall contribution is said to rarely deserve a starting place otherwise. Elanga started the season strongly before picking up a training injury.

William Osula, Aladji Bamba, Nico Gonzalez, Ewen Jaouen, Bazoumana Toure and Matias Fernandez-Pardo are listed as impossible to judge because not enough has been seen of them. Mark Gillespie and Nick Pope are placed in a separate category described as the other Newcastle United players. The writer says Newcastle need some of the problem players to prove themselves as real assets very soon. Newcastle were in 12th place with 12 points from 10 matches as of 14 November 2026.

What this means

Newcastle face Arsenal at home on 21 November 2026 and Brighton away on 29 November 2026. The schedule lists these fixtures but not confirmed lineups. Recent results include a 0-1 home loss to Everton and a 1-1 draw at Fulham.

What’s your take?

React, join the discussion or share this story with your fans.

Sources

THE NEXT STORY STARTS HERE

Keep reading

More stories connected to this one. Find your next talking point.

News archive →

The stands

0 comments

Have your say. Keep it about football. Guest comments are reviewed before appearing publicly.

Be the first to start the conversation.