FOOTBALL · THE CONVERSATION STARTS HERE

Penalty against Morgan Rogers sparks handball debate after Chelsea defeat

Story updated

Quick read

9-second read

Leeds beat Chelsea 4-1 at home after Morgan Rogers was penalised for handball. Chelsea manager Xabi Alonso called the award harsh, while Alan Shearer said officials are not allowed to use common sense.

Kickjolly
Morgan Rogers
BBC Sport · original article image

Full story

Chelsea suffered a 4-1 home defeat to Leeds, with the penalty against Morgan Rogers seeing Leeds take the lead for the first time. The spot kick was awarded by Michael Oliver, with VAR official Michael Salisbury taking no action. The decision has reopened debate over how Premier League officials interpret the handball law. The match was played on Saturday, 21 November 2026.

The background to the penalty is that Jayden Bogle shot from distance and Rogers raised his arm as the ball approached. Oliver judged that Rogers had moved his arm into the flight of the ball, making the contact a deliberate act under the laws. If his arm had remained lower and level with his midriff, there would have been no offence. The ball appeared to strike the red zone of the arm, which is punishable.

Xabi Alonso, the Chelsea manager, called it a quite harsh decision and said the given penalty ought not to have been awarded, while not making a big thing of it. Shearer, a pundit on the BBC programme, said he disagreed with the penalty and argued that common sense cannot be applied by referees. Shearer suggested that Rogers was not attempting to block the ball and simply did not want it to strike him in the face.

The incident was compared with a similar penalty awarded to Leeds last season, when Everton defender James Tarkowski leaned into the ball with his arm tucked to his side. Everton manager David Moyes called that decision wrong, though it was correct in law. Premier League clubs regard a fully extended, raised, or deliberately used arm as punishable. Chelsea were fifth in the table, with 16 points from 10 matches as of 21 November 2026.

What this means

Chelsea next face Nottingham Forest away on 27 November 2026, followed by Crystal Palace at home on 2 December 2026. Alonso and Shearer have voiced their disagreement, but the match result stands.

What’s your take?

React, join the discussion or share this story with your fans.

Sources

THE NEXT STORY STARTS HERE

Keep reading

More stories connected to this one. Find your next talking point.

News archive →

The stands

0 comments

Have your say. Keep it about football. Guest comments are reviewed before appearing publicly.

Be the first to start the conversation.