FOOTBALL · THE CONVERSATION STARTS HERE

Newcastle fans divided over Bruno Guimaraes return

Story updated

Quick read

10-second read

Newcastle United fans have shared their thoughts on Bruno Guimaraes ahead of Saturday's Premier League meeting with Arsenal. The former captain returns to St James' Park for the first time since leaving for the Gunners.

Kickjolly
Newcastle United fans Bruno Guimaraes
The Mag · feed photo

Full story

Newcastle United fans were asked for 50-word views on Bruno Guimaraes before Saturday's Premier League fixture against Arsenal at St James' Park, set for a 5.30pm kick-off. The former United captain returns to Tyneside, having chosen to leave more than three months earlier. Kickjolly collected responses from contributors without offering any leading prompts. The replies appear across two articles, with part one published earlier on Friday and part two following later that day.

Simon Ritter called him a trophy-winning captain but criticised a Wembley offside and a lapse that allowed Liverpool to score. Dave Marshall described him as part of the trio that jumpstarted five years of rejuvenation and triumph, calling him the club's heart and soul. Billy Miller said he finds it hard not to harbour love for the former captain and wishes him no luck at Arsenal. GToon praised him for dragging Newcastle up from a relegation fight and winning a trophy, adding that he wishes him well apart from Saturday.

After the takeover, Guimaraes was the symbol of the thrilling initial period, Chris Wann said, but his reputation was damaged as he left. Peter Scraton urged supporters to remember him as brave in possession and relentless in the press, warning that disappointment ought not to lessen the things he helped build. Joe Harvey noted the March 2025 Wembley trophy lift and questioned the jogging bottoms worn at the Emirates, according to Matt Busby. Davey Hat-Trick said he will not boo him, citing Premier League wage rules that prevented Newcastle from matching Arsenal's offer.

In part two, David Hutchinson said that as a club legend Bruno will be booed and deservedly so. David Walsh called him among the club's greatest players and said booing would make Newcastle look pathetic. David Punton described him as old news now. David Hartley said he was both a traitor and a legend, charging him with arranging a departure of the worst kind. Bones said he is no longer welcome, while Tom McColl wished him luck except in matches against Newcastle.

What this means

Newcastle United sit 12th in the Premier League with 12 points from 10 matches as of 2026-11-21 00:16 UTC. Brighton visit St James' Park on 2026-11-29 at 14:05 UTC, while Arsenal's Saturday fixture remains scheduled. Kickjolly's earlier preview of Arsenal's visit does not independently confirm this report.

What’s your take?

React, join the discussion or share this story with your fans.

Sources

Related reporting, in time order

2 reports grouped by topic; up to eight shown, newest first. Compare the original reports below; they may describe different developments or rely on the same information. Grouping does not establish confirmation.

  1. The Mag · reported · 2026-11-21 13:00 UTC

    We asked Newcastle United fans for 50 words on Bruno Guimaraes (part two) ↗

    On Friday, we asked Newcastle United fans for 50 words on Bruno Guimaraes. Saturday of course sees the former United captain return to St James’ Park. Bruno Guimaraes and Arsenal... You can click here to read the full article.

  2. The Mag · reported · 2026-11-21 09:37 UTC

    We asked Newcastle United fans for 50 words on Bruno Guimaraes ↗

    On Friday, we asked Newcastle United fans for 50 words on Bruno Guimaraes. Saturday of course sees the former United captain return to St James’ Park. Bruno Guimaraes and Arsenal... You can click here to read the full article.

THE NEXT STORY STARTS HERE

Keep reading

More stories connected to this one. Find your next talking point.

News archive →

The stands

0 comments

Have your say. Keep it about football. Guest comments are reviewed before appearing publicly.

Be the first to start the conversation.