FOOTBALL · THE CONVERSATION STARTS HERE

Arsenal fans split over Arteta's pragmatic title success

Story updated

Quick read

10-second read

Arsenal fans are divided over whether Mikel Arteta’s results justify a more cautious style than Arsene Wenger’s entertaining approach. Arteta led the club to the 2025/26 Premier League title and a strong Champions League position.

Kickjolly
Fans decide if Arsenal trading Arsene Wenger's joy for Mikel Arteta's results is worth the price
Credit: Stuart MacFarlane/Arsenal FC/Julian Finney via Getty Images

Full story

Mikel Arteta has delivered Arsenal’s first Premier League title since the Invincibles season, winning in 2025/26 after taking over from Unai Emery in December 2019. His methods have made the Gunners one of Europe’s strongest defensive sides, conceding a league-low 27 goals during that title campaign. The team has won nine of its first ten Premier League games in 2026/27 and sits near the top of the Champions League league phase after four matches.

TalkingPoints users have weighed in on whether that success is worth abandoning the free-flowing football associated with Arsene Wenger. One user said Wenger’s team was box office but could lose heavily on a bad day, while another stated that nobody enjoys Arteta’s football even though it wins matches. A neutral fan admitted preferring Wenger’s style but would choose regular wins if supporting Arsenal. An Arsenal supporter added that they do not miss being bullied by bigger sides under the previous approach.

Wenger managed Arsenal for 22 years and won three Premier League titles and seven FA Cups, the most by any manager in the competition’s history. His early record against Chelsea included 17 unbeaten games from 1997 to 2005, though he won only five of the next 28 meetings. Against Manchester United and Liverpool from 2004 to 2018, Wenger recorded six and ten wins respectively in 29 games against each side. He also beat Manchester City only three times in 15 games between 2011 and 2018.

In 15 Premier League games against Chelsea, he has recorded nine wins and four draws, losing only in 2019 and 2021. In 14 matches against Liverpool, he has recorded four victories, five ties, and one loss, with only a single defeat across the most recent nine encounters.

What this means

Arsenal’s next scheduled Premier League fixture is away at Newcastle on 21 November 2026, followed by a Champions League home game against Borussia Dortmund on 24 November.

What’s your take?

React, join the discussion or share this story with your fans.

Sources

Related reporting, in time order

2 reports grouped by topic; up to eight shown, newest first. Compare the original reports below; they may describe different developments or rely on the same information. Grouping does not establish confirmation.

  1. Arsenal Insider · reported · 2026-11-17 20:00 UTC

    Fans decide if Arsenal trading Arsene Wenger’s joy for Mikel Arteta’s results is worth the price ↗

    TalkingPoints users have issued a clear verdict on the growing debate surrounding whether Mikel Arteta’s pragmatic approach to delivering trophies is worth Arsenal abandoning Arsene Wenger’s brand of football.Wenger was...

  2. Arsenal Insider · reported · 2026-11-17 20:00 UTC

    Fans decide if Arsenal trading Arsene Wenger's joy for Mikel Arteta's results is worth the price ↗

    TalkingPoints users have issued a clear verdict on the growing debate surrounding whether Mikel Arteta’s pragmatic approach to delivering trophies is worth Arsenal abandoning Arsene ...

THE NEXT STORY STARTS HERE

Keep reading

More stories connected to this one. Find your next talking point.

News archive →

The stands

0 comments

Have your say. Keep it about football. Guest comments are reviewed before appearing publicly.

Be the first to start the conversation.