Newcastle fan lays out preferred side to fix attacking creativity
Story updated
Quick read
10-second readA Newcastle United supporter has published a preferred 4-2-3-1 lineup to address the team's attacking problems. The writer wants Sean Steur to play as the number 10, with Miley and Nico in the double pivot.

Full story
The writer describes the current Newcastle United season as unenjoyable and compares the team's clueless play to the eras of John Carver and Steve Bruce. They suggest that continuing with the current manager is not ideal, though they focus on how to make the best of the available squad. The analysis begins with a defence that started the 1–1 draw against Fulham, where the writer believes the back five can remain effective together.
In midfield, the writer identifies a lack of quality options for the double pivot and the number 10 role. They argue that Joelinton lacks composure, while Ramsey, Willock and Bamba are inconsistent or lost. The attacking options in the ten position, including Wissa, Willock and Ramsey, are described as unable to drop between the lines or make quick, accurate passes to the front line.
The proposed solution is to move Sean Steur into the number 10 position, supported by Miley and Nico behind him. The writer compares Steur's potential to Brighton's Pascal Gross, noting Gross's ability to wander deep and start attacks. This setup is intended to cover Steur's defensive limitations while exerting more control in front of the defence.
On the wings, the writer criticises Jacob Murphy and Anthony Elanga as touchline wingers, while suggesting Barnes is unwilling to take on full-backs. They propose playing Toure on the right and Pardo on the left, with Osula as the preferred striker over Wissa. Osula and Pardo, Steur, Toure, Miley, Nico, Hall, Burn, Thiaw, Dedic and Hornicek make up the full preferred lineup.
What this means
Newcastle United sit 12th in the Premier League with 12 points from 10 matches as of 18 November 2026. The club faces Arsenal on 21 November and Brighton on 29 November, though these fixtures are scheduled and not confirmed lineups.
What’s your take?
React, join the discussion or share this story with your fans.
Sources
- ReportingThe Mag ↗
- Club dataAPI-Football ↗
THE NEXT STORY STARTS HERE
Keep reading
More stories connected to this one. Find your next talking point.
Newcastle United is weighing a new stadium or St James' Park redevelopment plus a Woolsington training complex
Newcastle United is considering major infrastructure projects, including stadium options and a £190 million training complex. The club has authorised further feasibility work…
The MagNewcastle host league leaders Arsenal at St James' Park on Saturday
Newcastle United host Arsenal on Saturday at 5.30pm. The hosts point to a strong recent record at this time of year, including a 1-0 win over Arsenal in November 2024. Arsenal…
The MagAlan Shearer has now named his best all time Newcastle United starting eleven
Alan Shearer has been asked to name his all time Newcastle United starting eleven. The United and England legend accepting the challenge. Not a bad Newcastle United starting…
The MagNewcastle United faces ownership question after another summer of departures
Matthias Jaissle has Newcastle United in mid-table with the youngest squad in years. The club has moved to a develop-to-sell model after losing key players, raising the…
The MagFanSided app launches for Newcastle United fans in the United States
The FanSided app is now live on iPhone and Android, but only for users in the United States. Newcastle United fans can choose the club and tailor their feed to follow team news…
Newcastle ToonsNewcastle United have a young squad… but the numbers suggest we can’t use that as an excuse
Newcastle United’s youthful squad this season has been the subject of much conversation, with many putting some blame on it for the inconsistent results, but the statistics…
Newcastle ToonsThe stands
0 commentsHave your say. Keep it about football. Guest comments are reviewed before appearing publicly.






Be the first to start the conversation.