Manchester City might decry the 'Red Cartel' of Arsenal, Liverpool, and Manchester United, but is it real?
Story updated
The story in brief
13-second readManchester City faces potential sanctions that could exclude them from the Premier League's top tier, while other big-six clubs like Arsenal, Liverpool, and Manchester United have struggled to keep up with City's dominance. The concept of a 'Red Cartel' has emerged, suggesting a conspiracy against City.

The full picture
Manchester City faces potential sanctions that could exclude them from the Premier League's top tier, while other big-six clubs like Arsenal, Liverpool, and Manchester United have struggled to keep up with City's dominance. The concept of a 'Red Cartel' has emerged, suggesting a conspiracy against City. CBS Sports reports that City's defenders believe this triopoly is a result of Abu Dhabi protecting the Premier League.
The idea of a 'Red Cartel' has gained traction beyond City's supporters, with former Chelsea midfielder Joe Cole criticizing the Premier League's financial rules for locking out ambitious clubs. Cole stated that the regulations are not doing their intended job, and the Premier League's profit and sustainability regulations have been criticized for being ineffective. CBS Sports notes that City's breaches of 114 Premier League rules over nine seasons have raised questions about the level playing field.
Historically, Arsenal, Liverpool, and Manchester United have not always been dominant together, with the last season they all finished in the top four being 2008-09. The Manchester City takeover in 2008 marked a turning point, and since then, the gap between the richest and seventh-richest English clubs has narrowed. CBS Sports reports that the Premier League has become more competitive, with nine of the 20 richest clubs in the game being English.
At a glance
- Reporting status
- Reported
- Original publisher
- CBS Sports ↗
- Source published
- Clubs covered
- Arsenal, Liverpool, Manchester City, Manchester United
Attributed publisher reporting. Kickjolly has not independently confirmed the claim.
Source context
As two of their number face off at Anfield on Sunday afternoon, this would seem to be a good time to find yourself one of the so-called Red Cartel. Manchester City are facing the prospect of sanctions that would cast them out from the Premier League's inner circle, while those other big-six clubs that play in white and blue have spent half a decade retreating from the title race (as, it should be noted, have Manchester United). If City's sanctions land this season, it could be that Liverpool are the nearest rivals to Arsenal in the title race, another domestic crown carved up by the grand old dukes of the English game.
Source excerpt · CBS Sports
Read original report ↗THE NEXT STORY STARTS HERE
Keep reading
More stories connected to this one. Find your next talking point.
Arsenal face a very different Liverpool to the one Manchester City beat
Arsenal head to Anfield on Sunday with a six-point lead over Liverpool, but this is about as tough a time as any to be visiting. ...
Arsenal InsiderAdidas launches Arsenal, Liverpool and Manchester United home shirts for just £40
Every Premier League team has officially launched all three kits for the 2026/27 season and the first discounts are in.A Premier League football shirt costs as much as £120 for...
Football365Liverpool face Arsenal and Manchester United competition for Bayern star Lennart Karl
Liverpool are reportedly keeping tabs on Bayern Munich youngster Lennart Karl as Arne Slot considers potential attacking reinforcements ahead of the upcoming transfer…
CaughtOffsideLiverpool face Arsenal and Man United competition for €60m Bundesliga prodigy
Liverpool are reportedly keeping tabs on Bayern Munich youngster Lennart Karl as Arne Slot considers potential attacking reinforcements ahead of the upcoming transfer windows.
CaughtOffsideArsenal, Liverpool and Man United monitor Karl amid criticism at Bayern
After an impressive breakthrough campaign at Bayern Munich, Lennart Karl has faced difficulties both on and off the pitch since the start of the 2026/27 season.The 18-year-old…
BulinewsMan City: Enzo Maresca issues Erling Haaland and Antoine Semenyo injury updates before Brighton rematch
Plenty of returnees expected before second meeting with Seagulls this weekEnzo Maresca has confirmed Manchester City will have a full complement available as they host Brighton…
Evening StandardThe stands
0 commentsHave your say. Keep it about football. Guest comments are reviewed before appearing publicly.





Be the first to start the conversation.