Five reasons why Man United should resist the temptation of another managerial change and stick with Michael Carrick - opinion
Story updated
The story in brief
14-second readManchester United manager Michael Carrick is facing criticism for a poor start to the season, with the team in 16th place after eight games and just two wins in 12 games across all competitions. The Peoples Person reports that Carrick's future is uncertain, with several managerial candidates waiting to take over.

The full picture
Manchester United manager Michael Carrick is facing criticism for a poor start to the season, with the team in 16th place after eight games and just two wins in 12 games across all competitions. The Peoples Person reports that Carrick's future is uncertain, with several managerial candidates waiting to take over. Despite being expected to be sacked after a 3-0 defeat against Bournemouth, Carrick survived. The team's performance has been marred by instances of player discontent.
The Peoples Person argues that Manchester United should resist the temptation to sack Michael Carrick, citing a lack of suitable replacements. The article suggests that potential candidates, including Eddie Howe, Julian Nagelsmann, and Antonio Conte, may not be guaranteed to succeed at Old Trafford. It notes that a world-class manager like Luis Enrique or Carlo Ancelotti would be a different story, but they are not available. Other experienced managers like Unai Emery and Fabian Hurzeler have ruled themselves out.
The Peoples Person also points out that Manchester United have a history of managerial instability, having appointed seven permanent managers since Sir Alex Ferguson's retirement in 2013. The article argues that sacking Carrick would continue this cycle, and that the club should instead focus on addressing other issues, such as poor recruitment. It notes that INEOS's failure to deliver on their promise of "best-in-class" options has contributed to the team's struggles.
At a glance
- Reporting status
- Reported
- Original publisher
- The Peoples Person ↗
- Source published
- Clubs covered
- Manchester United
Attributed publisher reporting. Kickjolly has not independently confirmed the claim.
Source context
Manchester United manager Michael Carrick has faced a lot of criticism for an underwhelming start to the new campaign. The Englishman planted seeds of optimism among fans after a blockbuster revival last season, which helped them finish third in the Premier League and earned him the full-time job. However, hope has turned to despair in the past three months, with United now languishing in 16th place in the league table after eight games. With just two wins in 12 games across all competitions, and instances of player discontent, the odds are very much against Carrick at the moment.
Source excerpt · The Peoples Person
Read original report ↗Related reporting, in time order
2 reports grouped by topic; up to eight shown, newest first. Compare the original reports below; they may describe different developments or rely on the same information. Grouping does not establish confirmation.
The Peoples Person · reported · 2026-10-30 09:00 UTC
Five reasons why Man United must resist the temptation of another managerial change and stick with Michael Carrick – opinion ↗
Manchester United manager Michael Carrick has faced a lot of criticism for an underwhelming start to the new campaign. The Englishman planted seeds of optimism among fans after a blockbuster...
The Peoples Person · reported · 2026-10-30 09:00 UTC
Five reasons why Man United should resist the temptation of another managerial change and stick with Michael Carrick - opinion ↗
An analysis of why Manchester United should avoid a managerial change and stick with Michael Carrick despite a poor start to the season.
THE NEXT STORY STARTS HERE
Keep reading
More stories connected to this one. Find your next talking point.
Michael Carrick is facing a familiar Man United problem – but Chelsea clash could offer a way out
As Michael Carrick and Xabi Alonso both try to come up with gameplans for Saturday’s hugely significant first – and potentially last – meeting as coaches, both have felt an...
The IndependentThe uncomfortable reason why Bruno Fernandes had to remain Man United captain
Michael Carrick can be Manchester United’s conciliator in chief. When his relationship with Bruno Fernandes seemed to have broken down, it has been patched up. United’s manager…
The IndependentChelsea vs Man United: How and when to watch the match across the globe
Find out when and where to watch Manchester United's crucial match against Chelsea at Stamford Bridge, with broadcast details for fans worldwide.
The Peoples PersonCarrick will bring in the big guns for a surprise overhaul to the starting XI vs Chelsea - prediction
Manchester United could recall Bruno Fernandes and hand Joshua Zirkzee a surprise start against Chelsea, while Kobbie Mainoo is expected to return on the bench.
The Peoples PersonUnited must act now to sign 250-goal ex-PSG striker on free transfer after Sesko injury blow - opinion
Manchester United should consider a move for Mauro Icardi. The former Paris Saint-Germain striker is available on a free transfer.
The Peoples PersonMichael Carrick “not surprised” Man Utd stuck with him after Bournemouth humiliation
Michael Carrick spoke to the media for the first time since Manchester United held crunch talks over the head coach position. It looked like he ...
United In FocusThe stands
0 commentsHave your say. Keep it about football. Guest comments are reviewed before appearing publicly.




Be the first to start the conversation.